4 Lessons New Communicators Need To Learn Before Taking a Major Stage

By Dillon Smith. Dillon is the Content Manager for Carey Nieuwhof Communications and is a member of the Speaking Team. You can book Dillon to speak at your next event here.

By Dillon Smith

Raising up new communicators can feel like navigating a minefield. 

There is a tension that anyone trying to invest in the next generation of communicators feels. On one hand, you want them to get as many reps and opportunities to practice as possible. But on the other hand, you know that giving inexperienced communicators big opportunities can lead to catastrophic results. 

Since there is a massive difference between messing up in front of a small group of 15 people and messing up on a major stage, you want to give new communicators as many small opportunities as you can. 

But how do you know when a new communicator is ready to take on a major stage? 

As I look back on my own development and the development of others, there are pivotal moments when simple lessons went a long way.  

There is a massive difference between messing up in front of 15 people and messing up on a major stage. Give new communicators as many small opportunities as you can. Click To Tweet

Here are 4 responses to my early sermons that I needed to hear before taking a major stage: 

1. “You need to learn the rules before you can break the rules” 

A mistake many young communicators make is trying to preach with style before they preach with discipline. 

I have done this numerous times. 

Early on in my preaching career, I thought that as long as my preaching style was great, the audience would love it. 

Do you want to know what happened? No matter how many times I tried to preach with intensity, the audience never responded the way I expected. 

It confused me. 

I never understood how I could be so excited about a message and the audience could look so lost at the same time. 

This happened because I didn’t know the rules for effective public speaking and as a result, my “style” broke all the wrong rules at all the wrong times. 

I saw what other great communicators did and copied it, but I didn’t understand the “why” behind it. 

If you see what great communicators do, you can imitate it. But if you understand the “why” behind their “what,” you can begin to innovate with your own communication style. 

If you see what great communicators do, you can imitate it. But if you understand the “why” behind their “what,” you can begin to innovate with your own communication style. Click To Tweet

The only way I began understanding the “why” was a mentor making me apply discipline before I applied style. 

How did he do this? 

He created a list of things that a communicator needs to think about every time they speak. 

Then, he made write and deliver multiple sermons to him or a very small audience. After that, he would meticulously grade me on every single thing on that list. 

If you are looking to teach your young leaders (or yourself) to be a better communicator, try working on your speaking disciplines, not style. 

Here is a sample of the list I had to follow for every talk I gave: 

  • Define the purpose of every talk, and every point within the talk.
  • Every talk needs to be between 2 and 5 points that are pointing towards one main purpose. 
  • Write ALL of your main points before your sub-points, ALL of your sub-points before your sub-sub-point, etc…
  • Hook the ENTIRE audience with every opening line. 
  • Build credibility with your audience every time you speak. 
  • Every point, sub-point, and sub-sub-point must be exactly one sentence. No more, no less.
  • Have a specific purpose behind every story/illustration. 
  • End every sermon with fireworks. [This is usually metaphorical. ;)]

The list was longer, but I wanted to give you an idea of just how strict your standards should be while training. 

As I did this for multiple talks, I began to understand how each rule works together, and when and why it’s appropriate to break the general rules of public speaking. I began innovating.

Today, every single one of those disciplines has a clear, logical explanation of why I am or am not doing it for every talk I give.

Young speakers need to learn the rules to break the rules, and someone has to teach them. 

If a young speaker doesn’t understand the rules of public speaking, they are not ready to take a major stage. 

Young speakers need to learn the rules to break the rules, and someone has to teach them. Click To Tweet

2. “Your ability to think needs to exceed your ability to speak”

The person on stage needs to have a deep understanding of whatever they are going to talk about. If they aren’t, why should anyone listen to them? 

So how do you know if a young leader has a deep understanding of what he is expected to talk about? 

A general rule I follow is this:

If someone can’t converse about a topic at a high level, they won’t be able to speak about a topic at a high level. 

If someone can’t converse about a topic at a high level, they won’t be able to speak about a topic at a high level. Click To Tweet

So if you can’t have a serious, engaging conversation about the topic with them, they aren’t ready to preach on that topic. 

So how do you fix this? 

You have deep conversations about the topic with them months before they are set to preach on it. 

Give them books to read, podcasts to listen to, and experts in the field to learn from. 

After they have done their research, sit down, ask hard questions, and wait for them to come up with good answers. 

These will be some of the most formative conversations a young leader can go through. You are teaching them how to learn, think, and articulate their thoughts clearly.  

This will take a lot of time, but the young leader that comes out on the other side will be worth the effort. 

When you can have deep, engaging conversations about the topic with that leader, they are ready to take a major stage. 

3. “That was rough, but you’re just beginning” 

That sounds harsh, and maybe it is, but here’s the reality: 

Everyone who speaks from the stage will deliver a terrible talk. The real tragedy is that not everyone will learn from those terrible talks. 

Everyone who speaks from a stage will deliver a terrible talk. The real tragedy is that not everyone will learn from those terrible talks. Click To Tweet

The best thing an influential leader in the audience can do is pull that communicator aside a couple of days later and say: 

“Hey, I think you have a ton of potential as a communicator, but I think you could have done better. How do you think you can improve?”

This conversation is key. 

Applied honest feedback is what separates the mediocre communicators from great communicators. 

Applied honest feedback is what separates the mediocre communicators from great communicators. Click To Tweet

This conversation will be painful, but in the long run, that pain is good. 

When young leaders feel the pain of failing on stage, we become motivated to do everything they can to never fail like that again.

You have to let us learn from failure on a small platform, so we don’t fail on a major platform. 

When young leaders feel the pain of failing on stage, they become motivated to do everything they can to never fail like that again. Click To Tweet

4. “Do you think you could be called to this?” 

The journey to becoming a public speaker can be pretty discouraging. 

Not only are you signing up to do something that most people are more afraid of than dying, but almost nobody is good at public speaking the first few times they speak. 

So young communicators are: 

  • Terrified out of their minds.
  • Have a long way to grow. 
  • Able to choose to do anything else in the world besides public speaking. 

So why do they stick around? 

Usually, there is someone in their corner cheering them on and mentioning that they might be called to be a preacher or motivational speaker. 

Someone sees potential in them and asks, “Do you think you could be called to this?” 

So how do you know if you need to have this conversation?

I see 2 major indicators: 

  1. Passion – Do they deeply care about what they speak on?
  2. Character – Are they someone worth following?

Notice what isn’t on the list:

  1. Competency – Are they already good at public speaking?

Just because a young leader isn’t good at communicating now, doesn’t mean they never will be. 

Just because a young leader isn’t good at communicating now, doesn’t mean they never will be. Click To Tweet

Early on, natural gifting to communicate is a “nice to have” but not a “need to have” for potential public speakers.

But they’ll never learn to speak if nobody ever encourages them to try. 

The most important asset a young communicator has is a leader cheering them on. 

If you are an older leader and see a young leader who is passionate and has good character, consider challenging them to be a voice for what they are passionate about. Their voice is needed.

The most important asset a young communicator has is a leader cheering them on. Click To Tweet

Want A Complete Guide to Preaching and Speaking?

art of better preaching

When it comes to communication and preaching, there are a lot of ways to go wrong that you usually don’t expect.

Ever wish someone could come alongside you to walk you through the finer points of the art of better preaching?

That’s exactly what my good friend Mark Clark and I do in our course, The Art of Better Preaching. We’ve even got a full unit on how to leave your notes behind the next time you give a talk.

Every week, Mark and I preach to thousands of churched and unchurched people, Mark at Village Church in Vancouver BC, and me at Connexus Church north of Toronto. We have very different styles, which means this course is not a preach-just-like-me approach to preaching.

You can customize it to help you preach better messages, and it draws from the rich tradition of different approaches that actually connect with unchurched people. Plus, we share our best secrets on how to craft the best messages we know how to create.

In the course, Mark and I cover:

  • The Why and How of Preaching
  • How to Preach to the Unchurched
  • How to Give a Talk Without Using Notes
  • How to Craft a Killer Bottom Line So People Remember Your Talk Years Later
  • How to Stay Fresh over the Long Haul

And much more.

You can get access here!

How Do You Develop Communicators? 

What methods/practices do you use to develop leaders in your organization?

Leave a comment below! 

3 Comments

  1. Maie on August 29, 2019 at 5:49 pm

    Thanks for this article Pas.Carey. Very good points! They are helpful indeed, but I don’t have a leader that cheers me on or not even corrects the flaws in my preaching. That’s why I often read your article and with that am thankful. God blesses you!

  2. cyberflix apk on August 27, 2019 at 2:20 am

    This is the best motivating post for the stage fearers, easily new beginners has overcome they fear easily.

  3. Chase Boyer on August 22, 2019 at 7:31 am

    Currently, I serve with students, and I have them give their message at least 3 times. There are lots of in-the-moment feedback from myself, my senior, associate and sometimes my campus worship leader. I think getting more voices than mine in the room helps the student feel the weight of what they’re about to do and also gives them a greater sense of the entire church. I think it also shows them they’re important and they matter.

    Informal debrief is awesome, but these are some super practical tips I’m gonna try and take to my students. I love helping middle and high schoolers develop their voice on stage, and some of these questions and rules are gonna help me shape the conversation to some more concrete reflection. Thanks for the post!

Leave a Comment





This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.