5 Ways People Pleasing Undermines Your Leadership

Share This Post

Are you a people pleaser?

If you think you have no people-pleasing tendencies, just remember how you felt the last time someone criticized you.

Not fun is it?

Even those of us who don’t think we’re people pleasers feel the pressure to want to please people some of the time.

That said, many leaders—particularly ministry leaders—are well aware of their people-pleasing tendencies.

But people-pleasing can undermine your leadership in significant ways. In fact, people-pleasers rarely reach their leadership potential.

After all, everybody you want to reach is online. If you're not, you're missing them.  Click To Tweet

It Starts Innocently Enough

Most leaders don’t set out to be people pleasers; instead, we fall into it. Innocently.

Let’s say you propose an overhaul in how you do your weekend services. You want to make Sundays more open to outsiders, so the music, mood, approach and tone get slated for some dramatic changes.

Almost immediately you start to get pushback.

What about those people who have been here for a long time?

Do you really think those new people will pay the bills like we do?

Don’t you need to honour tradition?

If you make those changes, me and X other people might leave.

It’s difficult not to feel pressure in a situation like that.

Most leaders don't set out to be people-pleasers; instead, we fall into it. Innocently. Click To Tweet

Trying to Find Easy Street

Many leaders instinctively begin to look for a compromise.

Maybe we won’t go all the way with the planned changes.

Perhaps we could do two services, one for people who like it the old way and one the way we want to do it.

Maybe we introduce a mid-week or Sunday night option.

Okay, we do one service but we meet in the middle, with elements for everyone crammed into that single hour.

You get the idea.

And this pattern impacts leaders all the time in so many ways. Whether its how you approach your services, dealing with personnel issues (to fire or not fire a staff member or handling difficult volunteers).

It also impacts how you handle coworkers, bosses and even family.

At The End of 2023, What Would It Feel Like to Look Back and Have Accomplished Exactly What You Set Out To? 

If you are a pastor or church leader with ambitious goals for 2023, I will coach you through a proven, easy-to-follow strategy to set and achieve exactly what you set out to.

The Highly Productive Leader is a 30-day challenge to free up more time and find more energy in 2023.

5 Ways People Pleasing Undermines Your Leadership

If you’re on the impossible quest to please everyone, there are at least five ways people-pleasing will hurt you:

1. Ultimately, you lose the mission.

A key goal of leadership is to lead a diverse group on a common mission. That’s why leadership isn’t for the faint of heart.

When you try to please all kinds of people, you usually end up sacrificing the mission. You’ve suddenly got a lot of people (or a diminishing number of people, actually) going nowhere in particular.

Is that what you want your legacy to be? Didn’t think so.

When you try to please all kinds of people, you usually end up sacrificing the mission. Click To Tweet

2. You end up not liking who you’ve become.

People pleasers feel like they’re winning in the short term, but long term they are rarely if ever satisfied with the results.

After compromising again and again, people pleasers end up very unhappy with who they’ve become.

In an attempt to please others, they’ve sold out. When you’re tempted to people please, think about who you’d like to be a decade or two from now. Then act accordingly.

3. It becomes harder to hear the voice of God.

When you are trying to please all the voices around you, it becomes more difficult to hear the voice of God.

Scripture gets interpreted through the filter of the critics.

You can begin to avoid what you know to be right because it’s just…so…hard. Do you really want to lose the ability to hear the voice of God? Didn’t think so.

When you are trying to please all the voices around you, it becomes more difficult to hear the voice of God. Click To Tweet

4. Real leaders end up leaving.

Great leaders have a sixth sense that picks up people-pleasing.

When you give into multiple voices and the mission is in decline, your best leaders will make a beeline for the door.

They won’t make a lot of noise. They’ll just quietly disappear. And you will be left without great people around you and a bunch of people who still aren’t quite happy yet. Which leads us to number 5.

5. Nobody’s actually that happy.

You and I have heard it a thousand times: when you try to please everybody, you end up pleasing nobody.

Here’s why that’s true.

When you try to please a multiplicity of voices, you can’t follow a course that is clear or hone in on a singular purpose.

Compromise means the traditionalists didn’t get quite what they were looking for; neither did the progressives. Most people end up mildly discontent and you end up going nowhere good.

When you try to please everybody, you end up pleasing nobody. Click To Tweet

Well that defines the problem, but what about the solution? Here’s a post I did about how to find a better strategy when introducing change, and why most leaders get it backwards. (I hope it helps.)

Make 2023 Your Most Productive Year Yet.

If as a church leader you have ever wondered...

  • “How can I become a far more effective leader?” 
  • “How do some leaders get so much done?”
  • “How do I get ahead?”
  • “How can I realize a dream I’ve been holding onto for way too long?”

Then it might be the right time to make a plan that works. 

Without a system and group of motivated people to hold you accountable, your dreams often stay exactly that—dreams. A dream without a strategy is just a fantasy. A goal without a plan is just a wish. And a lifestyle shift without accountability is just a fad.

That's why I created...

The Highly Productive Leader. A 30-Day Challenge to Free Up More Time and Find More Energy in 2023.

The challenge is 30 days of:

  1. Uncovering why we go off track
  2. Ambitious goal setting
  3. Building systems that set us up for success
  4. Accountability and encouragement

It's my response to years of failed New Year's resolutions, missed goals, and unread stacks of self-help books. I'll guide you through a paradigm-shifting curriculum to ensure that 2023 isn't just "more of the same." You'll learn and implement all of this through on-demand modules, group accountability, and live strategizing sessions with me.

Share This Post
Carey Nieuwhof
Carey Nieuwhof

Carey Nieuwhof is a best-selling leadership author, speaker, podcaster, former attorney, and church planter. He hosts one of today’s most influential leadership podcasts, and his online content is accessed by leaders over 1.5 million times a month. He speaks to leaders around the world about leadership, change, and personal growth.